Why can quotes for two trolley furnaces of the same size range from RMB 200,000 to 800,000?

Published苏能工业炉工程技术团队&唐荔

There is an obvious price difference in the bogie hearth furnace of the same size. First, check the size definition, actual production tasks and delivery scope, and then check the configuration and business differences. The same length, width and height of the furnace chamber do not mean that the effective working zone, bearing, load heating, temperature performance and installation acceptance are the same; but the high price cannot prove that the equipment is more suitable for you alone.

The 200,000 and 800,000 yuan in the question are the quotations given by the questions. There are no corresponding two original quotations in this article, so it is impossible to determine which item has caused how much price difference, nor can these two numbers be regarded as the market price range of bogie hearth furnace. The following method is used to find out where the two plans are different.

Match the design duty as well as the dimensions

First, ask whether the size in the quotation is the external size, the geometric size of the furnace chamber, or the agreed effective working zone. Effective working zone is the loading area that can meet the process requirements according to the agreed conditions. Just looking at the nominal furnace chamber, it is impossible to judge whether the same batch of workpieces and fixtures can be arranged in the same way, and it is impossible to judge which positions the temperature requirements cover.

Even if the size definition is the same, continue to compare the total weight, fulcrum and load distribution of each furnace workpiece and fixtures. Light load, uniform spread and heavy parts are centrally loaded, and the tasks proposed for the furnace trolley platform, the bottom structure, the wheel track and drive are different. The quotation says the same "load", and it also depends on what loading conditions this number corresponds to.

When the temperature and operation system, load task and heat source mode change, the furnace lining, heating or combustion, furnace trolley structure and on-site support may be changed at the same time. You should first check the differences that will affect the whole design, and then compare the instrument brand or optional networking functions; this is a kind of price verification order, not a fixed cost ranking for all projects.

Equal temperature ratings and installed power do not guarantee equal capacity

The maximum use temperature is the same, which does not mean that the daily continuous work system and the workpiece heating process are the same. It is necessary to compare the actual loading of each furnace, what temperature to start from, how to arrange heating, soaking and cooling, and the complete production cycle. I only watch the demonstration of empty furnace heating, and I can't answer how long it will take to enter the next process after loading the workpiece.

The electric heating power is greater, and it is not automatically equal to the faster heating of the workpiece. Effective heating, furnace lining and fixtures heat absorption, heat transfer and on-site power supply conditions should correspond; the gas scheme needs to check the combustion, gas supply and smoke exhaust matching according to the same process tasks. The two heat sources should not only compare the unit price of equipment, and the new on-site supporting equipment should also be included within the same range.

There are many temperature zones and the brand of the control cabinet is expensive, which cannot prove that the temperature uniformity is better. You should check the effective working zone, test temperature, no-load or load status and judgment method, and then compare the requirements and verification arrangements under the same conditions. The temperature difference figure of the test conditions is not written, which cannot be directly used as evidence of high price and reasonable.

Ask which requirement each extra feature serves

Functions such as data preservation, formula management, networking and automatic entry and output of materials can have procurement value if they correspond to clear production organization, traceability or personnel arrangement. However, what functions have been added, what needs the buyer to cooperate with, and what information should be delivered clearly.

If daily work only requires simple procedures and records, there is no need to accept unused functions just because of "more advanced configuration". On the other hand, there are clear requirements for product traceability, and the low-price plan that lacks the necessary records cannot be regarded as the same delivery by manual supplementation after the fact. The judgment is based on your task, not the number of function names.

Compare prices on the same installed and accepted basis

One quotation includes transportation, installation, on-site connection, testing and information, and the other only includes the factory equipment. The two total prices do not correspond to the same delivery. In particular, "including installation", "guidance installation" and "buyer provides supporting equipment", it is necessary to continue to list the specific content and the boundary position, and we can't just compare these sentences.

Sort out the quotation differences into the following table, and ask the manufacturer to explain whether it is satisfied, where the difference is, and the quotation after completing the same range.

Comparative items What should be aligned with the two quotations? What costs or tasks may be involved? The basis for verification that should be requested
Size and loading Effective working zone, workpiece and fixtures, load distribution Furnace body, furnace trolley, furnace bottom, track and drive Size definition, furnace loading diagram and bearing conditions
Process and cycle Commonly used and the highest temperature, operation system, load process Furnace lining, heating or combustion, thermal engineering design and production capacity Schemes and verification arrangements under the same workpiece conditions
Temperature and control Test scope and status, necessary records and action functions Temperature measurement, control, recording and corresponding test work Function description, test conditions and delivery list
On-site and acceptance Transportation, installation, supporting connection, testing and training On-site work, professional support and verification fees Including, not including, the matters provided by the buyer and the position of responsibility
Business and service Tax transportation, payment, warranty, spare parts and service scope Quotation caliber and follow-up costs Quotation and terms of service with the same caliber
Bogie hearth furnace quotation four-layer check: design tasks, production capacity, necessary functions and on-site delivery
Check the design tasks, production capacity, necessary functions and on-site delivery according to the four-layer order of the text. Compare prices after aligning the same task and scope; the fourth level is not a fixed cost ranking, and the chart does not show the market price or cost proportion.

Are these different designs or different prices for the same delivery?

If the tasks of the first two layers are different, please ask the manufacturer to adjust the plan according to the same conditions first. The original price is not directly comparable for the time being. If the task is the same and the additional functions are different, quote the required functions separately from the optional functions to judge what problems are solved with the additional investment.

If the main technical tasks, acceptance and delivery scope are the same and there is still a price difference, the supply organization, delivery date, service and business conditions should continue to be compared, and the important differences should be explained. You can't find a reason for a certain price, and decide out of thin air that the cheap one is to cut corners, or the expensive one has a longer life and lower energy consumption.

When there is a quotation, two complete plans can be provided first, representing the workpiece and furnace loading conditions, process requirements and on-site scope. Jiangsu Suneng Industrial Furnace Co., Ltd. Engaged in the design, manufacture and system integration of industrial furnaces and heat treatment equipment, and provide installation and commissioning, transformation and after-sales support, according to which non-standard bogie hearth furnace schemes and supply differences can be communicated. The specific parameters and prices are determined by the project documents.

Hotline: +86-130-5298-6814; Email: 997518512@qq.com 。

Issued by: Jiangsu Suneng Industrial Furnace Co., Ltd.

Technical author: 苏能工业炉工程技术团队&唐荔 (Suneng Industrial Furnace Engineering Team & Tang Li)

References