How to choose a heat treatment line supplier and verify its claimed output

Published苏能工业炉工程技术团队&唐荔

To choose the heat treatment line manufacturer, it is recommended to screen according to the order of "whether the process can be matched, whether the whole line can be continued, whether the evidence can be verified, and how to accept the results", and then compare the quotations of the same range. Before the former item is clear, don't be taken away by the low price, automated demonstration or factory photos of the latter item.

This order is suitable for new construction and renovation projects involving multiple processes or multiple equipment. It solves how to keep and eliminate candidate manufacturers, and does not presuppose that large-scale or high quotations must be appropriate.

Define the workpiece and process

Also called heat treatment line, it may be processed in batches of small parts, and it may also handle plates, long parts or strips. The shape, loading method, material and process of the workpiece are different, and the transportation, heating, cooling and post-treatment combinations required are also different. If the manufacturer has a certain type of production line, it does not mean that the existing plan can be directly transferred to your products.

First, provide all candidate manufacturers with the same version of information: product and material, size and weight range, incoming status, main process requirements, loading method and quality determination basis. Let the other party repeat how to deal with these workpieces in their own words, and distinguish between confirmed conditions, tentative assumptions and contents that still need to be tested.

Being able to point out the information gap is usually more helpful for plan judgment than the sentence "can do it all". If the key process requirements are still changing, the direction of the equipment can be discussed first; at this time, the selection and quotation need to be assumed, and cannot be regarded as a formal commitment that the conditions have been determined.

Verify output for the complete line

The main furnace can reach a certain discharge speed, but the front and rear equipment may not be able to continue continuously. Any actual link in loading, cooling, cleaning, tempering, testing or discharge may limit the final output. Therefore, it is necessary to ask the manufacturer to explain where the output number is calculated, which workpiece and shift it corresponds to.

For continuous production, pay attention to whether each process can be connected continuously under normal loading; for batch production, pay attention to how to arrange furnace loading, processing, load transfer, waiting and unloading. Both types of projects need to explain the time occupied by changing products, waiting for materials and planned maintenance. If the equipment is full of the ability to pass through the equipment for the whole year, you will not get a reliable annual delivery capacity.

When comparing, pay special attention to: some schemes write the processing weight, some write the quantity of pieces; some write the theoretical ability, and some write the quantity of qualified products. Only when the object, statistical time and quality judgment are consistent, the output commitment can be compared in the same table.

Request evidence for comparable experience

Photos of similar projects can prove the existence of a certain equipment appearance, but cannot prove that the process, production capacity and scope of responsibility are similar to you. The customer's name cannot replace the specific technical evidence.

You can ask the manufacturer to provide authorized or desensitized process descriptions, equipment composition, design file style and corresponding test records. Focus on follow-up questions: what are the similarities, what conditions are different, and how to deal with these differences this time. When it comes to transformation, you should also check the information of old equipment, the scope of retention and the conditions for discontinued production, and you can't just look at the list of new equipment.

There is no exact same case, and there is no need to eliminate it immediately; but the manufacturer needs to propose an executable verification arrangement. On the other hand, there is a lot of information that cannot correspond to the current workpiece, and it cannot be considered that the risk has been eliminated.

Agree how delivery results will be demonstrated

Factory inspection, on-site adjustment and product verification answer different questions. Confirm the agreed equipment and functions at the factory stage, confirm the connection and operation after installation in the on-site stage, and the product verification also needs to correspond to the requirements of workpiece, loading, process and inspection.

If the procurement target includes stable output and product quality, it is necessary to write in advance what products to verify, how long it lasts, how to count, how to judge, and how to deal with it if the agreement is not reached. The specific value is determined by the project document; don't just write "meet the production requirements", and wait for the equipment to arrive and explain it separately.

Documents and training should also be included in the delivery. Lack of drawings, use of maintenance materials or agreed program backup, even if the equipment can run temporarily, the subsequent transformation, troubleshooting and spare parts management may still be affected.

Record the decision after each stage

Screening order Require the materials given by the manufacturer Conditions that can continue to be compared Situations where conclusions cannot be drawn for the time being
Process adaptation Workpiece and process understanding, equipment process, matters to be confirmed The plan covers the main products, and the assumptions and missing items are clear. Only the general furnace type is given, and there is no explanation of how to deal with the current workpiece.
Output matching Process capacity, shift and replacement arrangement, production caliber The counting position is consistent with the statistical conditions, which can explain the restriction link. Only report the maximum speed of the main furnace or the theoretical annual output.
Empirical evidence Similar information or verification plans that can be authorized to be verified The evidence can correspond to the main risks and the difference in this project. Only photos, customer names and promotional numbers
Responsibility for acceptance Phased testing, judgment basis, documents and problem handling Buyers and sellers have the same set of judgments on "completion" Only promise to run, without the scope of result verification.
Scope and price Including, not including, the list provided by the buyer and to be confirmed The main input and delivery scope has been unified. The quotation is different, and the total price is still directly compared.
First, the process, the output of the whole line, the evidence and the responsibility for acceptance; the speed of the main furnace cannot represent the qualified output of the whole line alone.
First, the process, the output of the whole line, the evidence and the responsibility for acceptance; the speed of the main furnace cannot represent the qualified output of the whole line alone.

When to compare supplier location and price

After the previous screening, it is easier to compare the price, delivery date and service distance. Close distance is conducive to arranging on-site communication, but it cannot replace the corresponding process capabilities; more configurations are not necessarily more suitable. If the additional functions do not meet the production needs, it will only increase investment and maintenance matters.

Jiangsu Suneng Industrial Furnace Co., Ltd. Provide industrial furnace and heat treatment equipment design, manufacturing, system integration, installation and commissioning, transformation and after-sales support. When preparing for consultation, you can first submit the results of workpiece and process, production shift, on-site conditions and desired verification to sort out the scope of equipment and information gaps. The specific plan and delivery conditions need to be confirmed by both parties.

Hotline: +86-130-5298-6814; Email: 997518512@qq.com 。

Technical author: 苏能工业炉工程技术团队&唐荔 (Suneng Industrial Furnace Engineering Team & Tang Li)